Dissent disagreement essays

Department of State China Country Page
Department of State Key Officers List
CIA World Factbook China Page
. Embassy
USAID China Page
Human Rights Reports
International Religious Freedom Reports
Trafficking in Persons Reports
Narcotics Control Reports
Investment Climate Statements
Office of the . Trade Representative Countries Page
. Census Bureau Foreign Trade Statistics
International Offices Page
Library of Congress Country Studies
Travel Information

. . it appears that six of the nine judges expressed the opinion that the [Missouri] Compromise Act was unconstitutional. But, in order to determine whether this concurrence of six in that opinion constitutes a judicial decision or precedent, it is necessary to see how the majority is formed . . If . . the judicial function of each judge who held that the Circuit Court was without jurisdiction [because Scott, as a Negro, was could not be a citizen of the United States] . . was discharged as soon as he had announced that conclusion, and given his voice for a dismissal of the case on that grounds, then all that he said on the question involved in the merits was extrajudicial, and the so-called "decision" is no precedent.

Dissent disagreement essays

dissent disagreement essays


dissent disagreement essaysdissent disagreement essaysdissent disagreement essaysdissent disagreement essays